passhas.blogg.se

1. #Compare aspen hysys and pro ii simulation and result trial
2. #Compare aspen hysys and pro ii simulation and result simulator

I'm trying to make a hydraulic model of a large oil tank storage pipeline system to calculate head, flow rates, friction loss, and minimum tank levels necessary. My application is pretty simple in that it does not include a lot of processes.

#Compare aspen hysys and pro ii simulation and result simulator

Hi, I'm also trying to decide which process simulator to go with. While you can make All the programs do the same thing, they are distinctly different in the applications they are well suited for.Īspen is traditionally considered superior in the chemicals arena, pro II in the refining space and unisim / hysis in topsides processing. Now - if we talk dynamics then it is much more complicated. With the underlying calculation engine and Phys props package from aspen and some of the niche features from Pro II. Similarly, the fact that aspen might be good at that one thing doesn't matter if the rest of the engineering houses you work with rely on pro II. unisim don't matter if you make use of specialized tools there anyway. Some of the elements that people may find lacking in e.g. From a technical stand point each has particular strong points, but in my experience what most users designates "the best" depends mostly on which program the user is most proficient in. In the end the "best" choice is likely to depend on: which contractors you work with (and what they have access to), the amount of custom calculations you need to do, the extend to which dynamic or real time models are Important and how much money you can convince your company to cough up.Īspen is traditionally considered superior in the chemicals arena, pro II in the refining space and unisim / hysis in topsides processing. I don't have personal preferences here - they are just tools to get the work done. I think, what you need to understand is that while you can make All the programs do the same thing, they are distinctly different in the applications they are well suited for. The invention of process plant simulators, such as Aspen Hysys, Honeywell UniSim Design, Pro II with excellent thermodynamic libraries impart the process. Taking the FE? Check out the FE Discord for study tips, advice, and more: NCEES FE/PE Discord

#Compare aspen hysys and pro ii simulation and result trial

Posts are frequently caught by the spam filter and it may take a few days to notice without contacting one of us.Ĭheck out the official Discord for /r/ChemicalEngineering: /r/ChemicalEngineering Discord progeCAD Professional in 2021 by cost, reviews, features, integrations, deployment, target market, support options, trial offers, training options, years in business, region, and more using the chart below.

If your post is not showing up, message the mods. Have a more general question? Try /r/AskEngineers It is not primarily for coursework or job hunting.įor student-related questions, visit /r/EngineeringStudents.įor job hunting and career advice, use our monthly sticky thread or the biweekly sticky thread on /r/engineering. This subreddit is primarily for practicing Chemical Engineers to discuss topics related to their discipline and the practice of engineering. If you don't see what you're looking for, then please post.